College Sports as Education, Should Business Schools Exist, and Higher Ed’s Gridlock

Tuesday, November 17, 2026 - College leaders often view athletics as a side issue, separate from the core educational mission of the institution. But what if colleges embraced sports as a way to develop social emotional learning and leadership in students? On this episode, Jeff and Michael reflect on these questions, drawing on a recent conference they attended that brought together leaders from youth sports, high school sports, and college sports, as well as former professional and Olympic athletes. Plus, whether business schools need to rethink their purpose, and how higher ed’s governance structures can stall action.

Listen Now!

Listen wherever you get your podcasts.

Join our Newsletter

Get notified about special content and events.

Chapters

0:00 - Introduction
1:30 - A Summit on College Sports
5:55 - Lamenting the End of Multi-Sport Athletes
8:57 - ‘The Promise of Education Has to Be True’
11:06 - Could ‘Sports Performance’ Be a Major?
13:00 - Is a Student Responsible for Learning, or Colleges?
14:23 - Giving Credit For What Athletes Learn on Teams
15:45 - Should College Coaches Be Licensed?
17:08 - Tension Between Winning and Personal Development
18:57 - Who Is Responsible for College Sports?
20:46 - Bringing Sports Back Into Educational Fold
22:18 - Sponsor Break
22:23 - A Critique of Business Schools Goes Viral
29:15 - Do Students Still Need College?
40:40 - Why Governance Is at the Heart of the Problem
40:34 - Wrap-Up

Relevant Links:

Follow the Money: Is NIL Good for College Sports?, ASU+GSV Summit

“Range: Why Generalists Triumph in a Specialized World,” by David Epstein.

Sold a Story podcast, Season 2.

“I Teach at a Business School. It’s Time to Shut Them Down,” in The New York Times.

“How Will You Measure Your Life,” by Clay Christensen.

“Reinventing College As Something Everyone can Use and Afford,” by Michael Horn and Joe E. Ross in Education Next.

Michael Horn

I went into this excited. You and I have hosted a number of conversations about athletics on the Future U. show.

That's why I think we got to be part of the advisory committee, if you will, for this new venture.

And then a lot is broken about college sports we've talked about, and we've said it's a big deal.

But my big takeaway, Jeff, was Sports has been seen as an extracurricular. I have framed it as an extracurricular. And my big takeaway was, that was the wrong framing. It's actually much more central and core to developing our youth to, frankly, the success of education in this country and maybe our secret sauce that has helped America innovate and thrive and lead in many ways, and there are a lot of problems around it right now.

Jeff Selingo

I think educators has essentially outsourced sports to private clubs, to private equity, to boosters, to conferences. Maybe I'm just old fashioned about this, but I think it's time to bring these back into education in a way where we could regulate it in a better way and we could control it in a better way.

I really think it's the governance system that was really built for a much different time in higher ed. And faculty governance is really built to stop things and not to start things.

Michael Horn

I actually think it's gonna be a golden era of college opportunity and necessity, frankly, for students.

Announcer

Subscribe to Future U wherever you get your podcasts. And if you enjoy the show, share it with your friends so others can discover the conversations we're having about higher education.

Michael Horn

Welcome to Future U, Jeff. good to see you.

We get these opportunities occasionally to have a one-on-one show where we get to run through our various lists of things that are burning or that higher education should be paying attention to.

We've been on the road, quite a bit, it turns out this fall, and our first conversation actually revolves around that because we were actually on the road together at this conversation with our friends at GSV Sports, putting on the first ever conference that I think brought youth sports, high school sports, college sports, professional, Olympics.

Jeff Selingo

Olympic. Yep.

Michael Horn

All in the same room.

And I thought we'd actually start there, Jeff, because I had a couple headlines coming out of it for me. But the first one was, I went into this excited. You and I have hosted a number of conversations about athletics on the Future U. show. That's why I think we got to be part of the advisory committee, if you will, for this new venture.

And then a lot is broken about college sports we've talked about, and we've said it's a big deal.

But my big takeaway, Jeff, was ... sports has been seen as an extracurricular. I have framed it as an extracurricular. And my big takeaway was that it was the wrong framing.

It's actually much more central and core to developing our youth to, frankly, the success of education in this country and maybe our secret sauce that has helped America innovate and thrive and lead in many ways, and there are a lot of problems around it right now.

Jeff Selingo

Yeah, Michael, that was really my big takeaway too. I'm a huge sports fan as listeners of this podcast know as we often talked about. And I think that people often think of college athletics as like a business now and like something as extra.

I think people in education always felt that high school sports and middle school sports and youth sports take up too much of the conversation about education.

But I came away from this day …and there were, you know, so many different types of people in the room. Right? There were nonprofits like Girls on the Run, there were people from Major League Soccer, there were obviously college presidents, there were people in K-12 and the Olympic movement, you know, former professional athletes there. So there were people from all different aspects of sports.

And what I realise is that it's really central to the social emotional learning development of our kids. It's really important to the executive functions of our kids. So I agree with you that it... I see it now as much more integrated into the education system or that it should be.

And I think what's been lost, Michael, especially, you know, I'm a Gen Xer.

Michael Horn

So am I. Jeez. Don't push me out.

Jeff Selingo

I know. I always think of you as …

Michael Horn

My wife might not be, but I am.

Jeff Selingo

But I think what's true, from when we were growing up, is that sports has really moved to...

One of the things I've come to realize and was mentioned a couple of times during this convening is that, first of all, sports has really moved away from the schools, particularly at the Pre-K through eight level, where a lot of that has moved, into private clubs.

It's also, by the way, moved away from communities. So often, during the day we were together... By the way, we were in Chicago at this convening. It was at the Obama presidential center. So we're gonna probably make a reference to that during this conversation.

So often, during the day, people kept talking about, you know, parks and rec leagues, you know, the whole little league. Like, all of that has just disappeared in so many communities.

And if you wanna play youth sports, you really... I kinda have to go through clubs or through your school, but even, you know, many K-8 have just given up on youth sports because it was too expensive to run through the schools and things like that.

And then you, of course, you get into the high school level. I know even at my kid's school, if you're playing on varsity, you're probably playing on a year-round club team as well.

This idea of, you know, multi-sport athletes in high school has has gone away. And then of course, we've talked a lot on this show about colleges as well and what's happening there.

And all of this, of course, leads up to what's happening now in the pros and what's happening on the Olympic movement.

So that's my big takeaway too is that this is a systems problem that needs a systems solution.

Michael Horn

Yeah. Well, so stay on that one because I came in with that mindset. It was one of the reasons I was so excited about all of them coming... All these different vantage points coming together.

And I'll give you one narrow lens through which I was excited about it, which is, we both have kids. They're both still, you know, athletically inclined and playing various sports and so forth.

And I've just been, like, I'd read David Epstein's book “Range” several years ago about the importance of generalizing and not specializing too quickly. And I've been really dismayed, frustrated, insert adjective here, at how year round all of these sports are. And if you sorta take a couple seasons off, you just fall so far behind because at this age level, the disparities can get pretty big pretty quickly.

And I guess I've been dismayed about that, Jeff, for a couple reasons.

One, it seems not super healthy for the individuals. You can have overuse injuries. You could have burnout, and so forth.

David makes a very compelling case. It's not actually the best way to develop talent, for the Olympics or pro sports level that actually generalizing, has huge benefits in terms of cross training and not burning out and things of that nature and waiting until you're in high school to really pick a sport or even later in some cases.

And so it hasn't seemed to me either a good individual strategy nor a good, national strategy, if you will, Jeff.

I came into it with that perspective, and I thought, ‘Well, the only reason, the only way we can break out of that is sort of if the Olympics and pro sports are sitting there to say, ‘Hey, this isn't in our interest. Let's sort of rejigger that.’ Right?’ They could reach across the transom.

And I thought of that in terms of the colleges as well, because so often this is a ticket in the minds of parents, if not in reality, to...

You know, I'm great at one sport. You'll take me so I can play at your college. One person, we're not allowed to talk about names, but at... One attendee said to me, you know, it used to be the person who was the 9, 10, right, varsity sport athlete in high school was seen as, like, the biggest award. And now it's like, oh, that's the person who's not gonna play in college because they were probably average at everything.

Sort of a sense of loss for me about that and thinking the only way we could rejigger it is to rejigger the financial incentives.

The reason I give that long preamble is I left also feeling like, ‘Wow, that is one perspective of one problem facing sports.’ But there were many different perspectives and priorities around what's the most important thing to fix, if you will, or to change.

And,w e could name some of the central... some of the tensions, maybe we will, but I think there's... I'll just name one of them, which is colleges, I think, are having this tension around my financial interest as a school versus the well-being of my students.

Well, depending on which one you prioritize and where you make your trade-offs, your quote unquote solutions are very different.

And so one of the things I left feeling is like, I'd actually love a conference where we just named what is your priority problem. We all just put them out there before we even thought about solutions.

Jeff Selingo

Yeah. Michael, it was interesting because on...

Both of us participated and moderated panels and other discussions throughout the day. We were together.

And, you know, sometimes when you're moderating a panel, it's hard to kind really pay attention to a lot of the themes because you're kind of thinking about the next question you wanna ask. so I often will ask you, ‘Hey, what really happened during the panel that I moderated?’

But there was a moment that I will not forget. And Len Elmore, a former University of Maryland basketball player in the early seventies, ended up going to Harvard Law School, was a practicing lawyer, played in the NBA. Has been a TV commentator for college basketball.

You know, one of the things he said at one point, because my panel was focused on... The panel I moderated was focused on, like, what has to be true about college sports going forward? No matter what happens, and there's a lot of changes as we know in college sports. What really has to be true?

And the panel really came back to something that's not surprising is that, you know, the promise of education has to be true. But what that really means is very different.

But something that Len said during the session really actually stuck with me all day. He talked about being a student at the University of Maryland. He was actually a student. Right? He able to, like, major in what he wanted to major in, go to classes, you know, have roommates, participate in campus life, which I thought was really critical. And all of that made him the person that eventually led him to Harvard Law School.

And I was thinking about how different that must be now for elite Division I athletes who from what I can tell from where I sit are just... First of all, they're moving from institution to institution. So they're not even on a campus for four years now.

But even when they are, it is all as many people talked about it at this conference, it's all transactional. I'm there to play a game and that's it.

Michael Horn

So, Jeff, I wanna actually dig into that because that was one of the two central tensions that also came out were around this question.

One was the perspective you just talked about, which is I'm an athlete, but I should be able to have the student experience everyone else is having.

I don't know if it was stated so clearly, but there was another view in the room and on your panel, which was, ‘Well, student athletes have a whole set of experiences that the rest of the students don't have, and maybe that's okay.’ Right?

And so I... I'm not taking a side on this except just to note that actually sort of athlete that gets the rest of the student experiences versus athlete just having a different track and maybe that being okay, that was one of the tensions that I think people in the room had very different perspectives around and and would optimize very differently around.

It related to something that one of the panels I moderated came out with, which was, there... is a movement to make sports performance as its own major and how that would flip the entire paradigm of this conversation on its head.

And you could imagine if you're an athlete, on a particular team, you might choose to major in sports performance. That major might have finance classes about how to manage wealth. It might have, you know, marketing classes about how to manage your brand, about physio, things around health and wellness and stuff like that, as well as perhaps, you know, a core of, if if you think well-roundedness is an important part of, any any college experience, you know, some distribution requirements or something like that. Right, Jeff?

So that as you're developing these durable skills around leadership, communication, working with others, and things like that, that there's some transfer as you maybe go post-college.

So that felt like an interesting tension in the room, if you will.

The other one I will say also came from your panel, which was a college president making the point that just because we have them for only a year or only a semester doesn't mean we can abdicate responsibility over their time with us here.

And that came out as well on my panel from someone.

And their analogy that they used was just because a faculty member only teaches a student for one semester doesn't mean that they cannot be responsible for their growth. I loved that line. My only editorial to it was, ‘Well, actually, often faculty do not feel responsible for every student's growth. In fact, they often see their course as something that might weed out students.’ Or they're... You know, they don't have the attitude, like if you're listening to the ‘Sold a Story’ podcast right now from Emily Hanford that I've only taught it if the student has learned it. Their view is often, well, I taught it. It's their responsibility.

And so I actually thought in an interesting way, that's a microcosm into one of the bigger tensions on college campuses, period, Jeff, at the moment around whose responsibility is it anyway, around student development and learning.

Is it the students to take control of themselves, or is it... Does the institution have some responsibility regardless of how much time an individual spends there?

Jeff Selingo

Yeah. Two thoughts on that, Michael.

One is on... I thought the whole conversation around giving credit and a lot more credit for student athletes for what they're doing and what they're learning as part of their team and then adding on things like personal finance and branding and things like that to really make this...

To really recognize, especially at the Division I level, what this has really become, which is a significant part of their undergraduate experience.

In fact, in the room that you moderated, I was sitting at a table with a Division I associate athletic director who talked about how they give credit. This is a pretty elite university. They give credit for athletes during the season for playing, and they were wondering whether they should even give more. So I think that's pretty critical.

You talked about the time that these students are on campus. I mean, there was a thread throughout the day that everyone agreed around the transfer portal now, which is a big issue in college sports, is that we do need to reduce the number of transfers though somehow.

Because there was a statistic given near the end of the day that every time a student transferred, right, their chances of graduating are reduced by something like twenty five percent.

And so what, you know, what is happening with these students who are transferring multiple times because of sports, are they ultimately getting their degree?

And then one other thought, from another room that we happened to be in together, later on in the day was around coaching.

Michael Horn

Yeah. I had the same note.

Jeff Selingo

I found that to be a fascinating conversation because we often think of the coach as like an extra. Like, not central to the, to the undergraduate or experience of of athletes.

But we know that athletes are gonna spend more time with their coach probably than anybody else. I mean, by the way, that's not just on college campuses. It's in schools. It's in, you know, community organizations. It's within these clubs. And how do we professionalize coaching?

There were two things that somebody said that I thought were interesting. One is that, you know, we tend to put all of our effort into the pro coaches when it's... It should be flipped. All of our effort should be put into coaches at the very beginning of a student's journey in a sport because that's when it's most important.

And then second, I love these ideas on how to professionalize coaching in a way. You know, accrediting them much like we accredit teachers. there was an idea that we should have like Coach for America, like Teach for America, which I thought was a terrific idea.

Like, a lot of people wanna become coaches, and they don't see, necessarily, a pathway, unless they become a teacher, or they're really lucky and they hit the lottery in college.

Michael Horn

Yeah. So I love that conversation as well. It got... Although I will say it hit on another tension I observed. So I'm all about observing, I guess, the unspoken tensions.

I'll say that in a moment.

Just to double click on what you said there first about the importance of coaching. I wrote down in my notes, sports prepares leaders in a very sort of Greek ethos kind of way, harnessing back to that time, right, of development of character and things of that nature. And there was this sense of coaching American youth to greatness, sports as life's original learning accelerator, and the role that, right, coaches as teachers that came up over and over again in some ways maybe more influential for many, many people.

What was interesting to me among the tensions there was this tension over winning versus development.

And, you know, some people pushed back and said, ‘Well, actually, if you take, you know, Nick Saban like, you focus on the process, right, and the journey, then you will get... like, the results will follow.’

But we all know that there are coaches who say, ‘Well, if I stack my roster at the youth sports level with people who are on the older end of the spectrum and therefore have developed quicker, I might also win. And that's gonna be better for my career if I wanna get a job at high school and then a job in college coaching and so forth.’

And so one of this comes back down to, I think, incentives and what are we really rewarding people for in their careers, I think is really important.

The other piece of this that I thought, you could summarize that maybe as winning is not enough, like it... It's gotta be part of the equation, but it's not the whole equation. I think that would go to your point around a certification or some sort of professionalization of coaching.

But I did have this other sort of thing that came out of all this was there is another tension between mission and margin in all of this, it seems. The fiduciary responsibility is, you know, this is a conversation you and I have had several years now around how the fiduciary responsibility of boards is to the mission of the school.

There is, you know, definitely the sustainability of the school, though, is on the minds of many of these leaders in terms of these tug and pull, if you will, of some of these conversations, and certainly easier to make a buck by going big around D1, Jeff.

And so I think that's something that plays out as well, and it goes to a question you asked around who's really in charge at the end of the day. Who is responsible for where all this goes? And once again, I think it's maybe the part of the institution that's least equipped to be in charge, which is the boards. But they have to think about, ‘What does our mission really mean and have some hard conversations about that.’

I want your reaction a second, but one last thought.

You know, there was another view in the room. I think it's after you left at the very end of the evening. It got expressed on stage, which was, you know, this is like a 5% problem in college athletics, and 95% is just fine. And if we just split it off, professionalize the 5%, sort of something I've said before, you know, just have for profit professionalized leagues, and then we can worry about those issues, and then the 95% will sort of go back to the way it is.

You sent me an article suggesting in this mission conversation, that's probably not true. Division III is actually facing a lawsuit right now as we know around us not scholarshipping its athletes in terms of merit. So this is a much bigger set of problems, it seems like, than just, you know, football, basketball, etcetera.

Jeff Selingo

Yeah. And, Michael, and I think my really big takeaway from the day is kinda where we started this conversation today is that I think educators have essentially outsourced sports to private clubs, to private equity, to boosters, to conferences. And I think it's really...

Maybe I'm just old fashioned about this, but I think it's time. If we think this is important to the social emotional development of students, if we think this is important to their executive function skills, if we think this is important to the soft skills that we know are critically important in this day and age, if we think this is important, I guess we kind of outsource the arts. We kind of outsource a lot of what we always considered extracurricular activities. I think it's time to bring these back into education in a way where we could regulate it in a better way and we could control it in a better way.

Maybe as everybody says, you know, the genie's out of the bottle, the toothpaste is out of the tube, you know, pick your favorite one on that level. And maybe we can't.

But I still think there's enough people that care about this as central to the educational development of our kids, that we should. And that's kind of where I'll leave it. …

Michael Horn

Do you know what I think would help, Jeff?

A mastery transcript that focused on these durable skills.

Alright. I got my thing in. Alright.

Jeff Selingo

You got your in. Why don't we take a break?

And when we come back, I know we have a couple of other things to get through in this episode, and we'll be back in a minute.

Jeff Selingo

Welcome back to Future U.

And, Michael, I think we wanna talk about two other headlines or two other things that have been on our mind the last couple of weeks.

One is this guest essay in The New York Times, which got a ton of play, headlined, “I Teach at a Business School. It's Time to Shut Them Down.” And it really was focused on, kind of the commercialization, the profiteering of business, how people come into business school.

What really struck me about this piece was how students come into business school really wanting to solve problems and using the business element of that, the business lens of that, to solve those problems. And many of those are big societal problems, climate change, and food, and income insecurity, you name it.

But they quickly just really focus on how to make more money and often do that at tech firms, at big banks and at consulting companies. And thus, the problem is not the students. The problem is the messenger or in this case, the vehicle, which is the business school.

You went to one of the top business schools in the world. How did you feel about this?

Michael Horn

How did I feel about this? Well, I was struck by how viral it went. I was surprised

Jeff Selingo

Everywhere.

Michael Horn

A little bit everywhere. Why?

Jeff Selingo

Well, I think it's because it's a, you know, a business school

professor writes it. Right?

Michael Horn

I guess that's why.

And I'm curious, like, if he would have chosen the headline. Right? It's often these headlines, take it bigger because I was sort of like I teach at a business school. It's time to shut them down. Well, good luck with that.

But I guess I had a couple reactions, Jeff.

One, there's an implied assumption, and I'm gonna say this is the person who went into a mission-driven quote, unquote education work. Right? That these other professions that individuals choose to go into are somehow less worthy.

And I think that carries a lot of value judgment on its own by the author of the piece, Chris Markey. And I'm not sure, a lot of the individuals would see it that way when they go into, you know, creating employment for other individuals as its own good. It creates taxpayer dollars that pays for health care that a lot... Education, a lot of services, and so forth. It...

A lot of these people will have a second and third acts that are more charitable in their lives.

Jeff Selingo

And can we pause there for a second, Michael. The second and third acts. I'm wondering how much of this is a recent phenomenon and how much of it...

I know you go back to your HBS reunions a lot. I'm assuming that among your classmates, they're doing a variety of things, right?

Michael Horn

Huge variety of things.

And in some ways, I actually thought the examples around consulting and banking were interesting because they felt a little passé of the current classes.

Almost everyone there wants to be an entrepreneur is my understanding of the current ilk.

I think what's interesting to me is this. Business school was actually... I often joke it made me less ambitious, but in the sense that it made me think about, like, life balance issues around, like, what kind of family do I wanna raise? What kind of dad do I wanna be? What kind of partner do I wanna be my eventual wife?

These were the sorts of conversations we had a lot at business school.

And, like, there's a reason Clay Christensen's How Will You Measure Your Life, Jeff, became the most popular lecture right at the end of the year for business school students was they were asking for this meeting.

And in my experience in coming back to reunions when I get together with my section, and some of them have passed away sadly, and we get together and remember them.

But we also just talk about life and books we're reading and trade offs we're making and challenges. That's the conversation that gets very real. Like, fifth reunion was very still peacocking. What job do you have? And I couldn't explain what I did., But then it gets very into the sort of these life questions, and how are you contributing, and what's important to you and your family and community.

And so to me, it felt like a caricature, Jeff, of a business school as of the article as opposed to what my sense of the conversations really are about on the ground. Overlaid with a sense of judgments about what is a better or worse job choice that someone might take.

And look, yeah. Some of the case studies, do I think they could be better? Yeah. Frankly, I wish that they were simulations where you couldn't do what I often did in class where I would say, ‘Oh, I would do both option a and option b,’ which as you know from running a company, Jeff, that's not... You have to make choices.

I wish there... You know, there are better ways, I think, to do business education than are done today, but I don't think it's, like, the fault or some corruption underlying the basic structure.

And look, business, we live in a capitalist world, where the allocation of capital toward things that we value is the most efficient way we found to to drive society so far and increase prosperity. And by the way, when countries become more prosperous, they become more green, they actually start... They stop burning as much fossil fuels. There's like a whole bunch of downstream benefits that happen out of this that I think is its own good, that were very easily dismissed, in that piece.

And so that's sort of my set of reactions on it, think, Jeff.

Jeff Selingo

It's funny, Michael. I looked recently because they never opened comments on this piece. The Times didn't. And I've done, you know, an oped for The Times, and they often ask the author if they wanna open comments and they participate in it. So maybe this professor didn't want to.

But I also wonder, by the way, you know, business education is under tremendous strain right now as we know. Right? MBA programs are changing. There's some of them are shutting down, but they're definitely changing.

And so I'm wondering if some of this might be just a natural evolution of business education over time anyway, what's happening with the MBA now.

Michael Horn

Well, stay with that because when you first sent me the headline over text, and I first saw it from you, I think I was getting back from travel. My initial reaction was, ‘Oh, it's gonna be about how MBAs are struggling.’ Right?

And I think that is true. Like, I think business education is in deep trouble for a whole host of business-model and disruptive innovation reasons, frankly.

But to your point, Jeff, that that wasn't what this piece was about.

But I do think that there will be natural evolutions in that field that speak to the things that people want over time.

And places will have reputations, right, that will grab it and, you know, draw students over time as well to people that are having the sorts of conversations that that that you want them to be having.

Jeff Selingo

So, Michael, you mentioned at the top of the show we've been traveling a lot. I know we often trade where we're speaking,

And I think both of us have, like, trying to, have developed new, you know, talking points or more new keynotes, this fall. I'm kinda curious kind of what's your big, big thing, your big thrust of your keynote, this fall, because I know that we've been working on that over the summer.

Michael Horn

Yeah. And I'll try to be succinct, and some people who've listened to us, Jeff, may not be surprised because I feel like the... I've actually used, I feel like, Future U. to develop some of the ideas over time.

Jeff Selingo

If you're if you're gonna have a podcast, why not use it

Michael Horn

Why not?

Michael Horn

Yeah. So, obviously, AI is a huge talking point. People are very interested to have me talk about that in the same way that they were interested 15 years ago to hear me on online learning and disruptive innovation.

And, you know, I start out with this big thing that, like, most faculty and many students are seeing AI as a threat right now. They talk about plagiarism, cheating, cognitive automation. Right? All these things.

And what's actually interesting about this is it's not that anomalous from how all technologies tend to be received in fields. You were in the newspaper industry. The Internet was seen as a threat. You look at electricity. Right? The introduction of that in factories, seen as a threat initially. You look at vacuum tubes disrupted by transistors, seen as a threat initially.

And the challenge I think comes when you frame it as a technology problem rather than one of the model in which it's used.

And so I talk about how do you reframe it not as a technology problem, but one around the model itself and what we're trying to achieve, the business model. It's that dirty word that no one in higher ed likes to talk about, but as I say, just like an eighth grade health class, we all have them.

And so how do you sort of reframe through it... Through changing your business model or the processes and the resources and and the value proposition, what you're trying to achieve, then you can ask how is AI an opportunity actually for us?

And so I... You know, look, there's the pure disruptive innovation story, and I talk about that. Western Governors University, UMass Global, others are employing a dual transformation strategy of creating, you know, sort of offshoots, if you will, brand new business models to reimagine how they deliver education using AI.

And then I talk about how there's a lot of new startup universities that are AI native institutions, and I have a slide with dozens of them, on the page.

And a couple of them have already failed. nd that's part of my argument, Jeff, is that a lot of these are not gonna work. And so we have to be measured as we walk into these things and think about the impact we really wanna have, and will they really wanna take off?

My next point is that we don't always need full-scale transformation, that sometimes this is gonna be like The Ohio State University or Purdue or Pace saying, ‘Hey. Every single major is gonna have an AI preparation component in it, but really the process reinvention is gonna take place within the departments, within the majors themselves. And that looks like something.

And then I leave it with sort of the nonnegotiable, if you will, of change in my view is because the half-life of skills is shrinking faster than ever, and that higher ed needs to become much more immersive or experiential as we've talked. I give a theoretical explanation for it, but I basically say we're in a moment where because what industry is gonna want you to do, what post college is gonna want you to do is less predictable, specifiable, and verifiable. Learning by doing is way more important.

And by the way, to get people jobs, they need to have real world experiences as part of that college experience as well. That's the new imperative is getting students real experience while they're students. That means everything from simulations to embedded projects to externships, paid internships, co-ops, apprenticeship, research opportunities, frankly, as immersive opportunities.

And I sort of go through each of these and say, there's another number of ways to do that.

They all change assessment, though. We are gonna see a lot more oral defenses, a lot more simulations being sort of real time assessed by ambient AI around us, presentations and demonstrations before in-field professionals.

One of my boogeymen, as you know, back to mastery based learning, I think separating who teaches from who grades, I think, is gonna be really important, Jeff.

Using AI to provide feedback and continuous improvement, and and and the like.

And then I talk about mastery based learning and sort of repositioning assessment so that right now students feel like, hey, this is a zero sum game. If I win, Jeff loses, and so therefore I gotta do everything I can just to get ahead of them. I'll use AI to cheat because it'll get me ahead and that'll make me look better. And my argument is if you move to a competency or mastery based learning model, it changes it from a zero sum to a positive sum game.

I try to get all of my students to master the material. Right? And so if they cheat, they're just cheating themselves at the end of the day. And so that changes a little bit the conversation.

And then I end with this last thing, Jeff, which is, 1976, there was a cover of Newsweek magazine that said, ‘Who Needs College?’

Jeff Selingo

Yep. By the way, I

had that same one in my my most

recent

Deck, too.

Michael Horn

Really?

Michael Horn There you go.

Jeff Selingo

We might be making a different point

about it, but go ahead.

Michael Horn

So then I say, there was also an image as you know in 1989, where Matt Groening created something for Apple saying, who needs a computer? And I make the point that both are sort of laughable questions in the decades since.

Jeff Selingo

Alright.

Michael Horn

And yet many people are asking who needs college anyway right now. And my argument is actually there's maybe no more imperative time for experiential opportunities through your postsecondary education than right now.

And so I actually think it's gonna be a golden era of college opportunity and necessity, frankly, for students, but it's gonna require some reinvention, really leaning into the experience that students have with each other, students have with faculty, students have with the world outside of them doing projects.

Jeff Selingo

Yeah. And I use that same image in my most recent keynote around kind of the threats that have faced higher ed over the years, including this idea that, you know, who needs college even way back in the seventies.

And by the way, it was followed by decades of huge growth in higher ed after that.

But my focus right now is... So I was asked this fall to speak to the University Risk Management and Insurance Association. Right?

Michael Horn

Wow.

Jeff Selingo

A huge group of risk managers. My wife is, as you know, is a

risk manager …

Michael Horn

I was gonna make a sarcastic comment, but I don't wanna insult her. Yeah.

Jeff Selingo

Jeff Selingo

And so she's like, ‘You better do a good job because, you know, a lot of people she knows, were going to be at this conference.’

So we're talking a couple hundred risk managers, and I think when people think of risk management in higher ed, they think of all the things that could go wrong on a college campus, which is like a small city.

But I think there are these enterprise risks that, you know, rise to the level of board level. Right?

So think of, you know, we talked about sports earlier. That's an enterprise risk. We've talked about research and the federal government, like the geopolitical issues are enterprise risk. AI is an enterprise risk. Right? If we... If our entire degree is built on this idea that it is a signal to the job market and now suddenly AI is gonna change that, right, that is an enterprise risk.

And so I was asked to, like, name the biggest risk of facing higher ed.

And I think everybody thought that I would name something like AI or geopolitical or things like that. But I really think it's the governance system that was really built for a much different time in higher ed. I would argue a much slower time in higher ed and not really built for multiple things coming at it at the same time.

Now, Michael, we have on the show talked about boards. Right? We've done a number of shows on boards. You know, they're... At the public level, they're built for, you know, political patronage. And on the private side, they're built for donors.

We've talked a lot about presidents and, you know, the fewer number of presidents staying very long in higher ed. And so they leave, you start over again.

And then we haven't talked as much, although we will this year, hopefully, on faculty, which... And faculty governance is really built to stop things and not to start things.

And the result of all of this is really this loss of momentum just when speed really matters most. Right?

And I think each group is to blame. Right? So I think boards like to blame presidents. Presidents like to blame faculty. Everybody likes to blame the board, and nothing gets doneas a result.

And we know especially among faculty, we really... And it's not just among faculty, but faculty presidents and and and boards ultimately, we have to make it worth everyone's time to compromise and worry less about consensus.

You know, there was a time, years ago when, when we were trying to name something new at The Chronicle of Higher Education. And somebody said, oh, we should name it “collegial” because higher ed is collegial.

And I said, there's nothing collegial about higher ed. Right? There's... It's it's just a big political operation Michael Horn

Totally.

Jeff Selingo

where everyone is trying to outgun and outwin someone else.

And that moment means nothing gets done. And because we have this idea of shared governance, nobody can kinda step in and just say, well, forget about what the faculty think. Forget about the... What the president thinks. The board is just gonna make this decision, or the president's just gonna make this decision.

And so we're just stuck in time, as a result, and nothing is getting done.

And so I believe that we need to come up with a new system that is less about consensus, much more about compromise, much more about making these trade-offs as we've talked about on this show.

And that to me is the biggest risk because nothing else gets done in higher ed unless we fix this. To me, this is the ultimate thing we have to fix before we worry about research, we worry about program cuts, we worry about athletics.

Michael Horn

Yeah. No. You're right. I mean, trade-offs, if you're not willing to make a trade-off and make a decision, then paralysis is the result. Right, Jeff?

And so it's a very well taken point. I think it extends frankly to the previous two topics we just tackled as well, sports, business schools, being able to make choices, being able to make decisions.

And look, knowing that there's no perf... Perfect. I mean, I talked about all the different tensions. Right?

At the end of the day, different schools are gonna have to put their thumb on the thing that is most in line, I would argue, with their mission, right, as they make these choices, and they're gonna have to act. Not acting is itself a decision, and it's generally not a productive one in the current time. Would agree, Jeff.

Jeff Selingo

Well, and with that, Michael, another episode of Future U. is in the books.

Thank you, everyone again for listening, for sharing with your friends and colleagues and counterparts, our show this year. continue to rate us, continue to give us reviews, follow us on social media, and share the message that we're trying to spread, with Future U. now in its tenth season.

And we will see you next time on Future U.

Wherever You Listen to Podcasts